Why this sudden rush?

We often live in worlds that are completely sealed off from others in the same city. Most of my friends are not aware of how other people, such as gays or eunuchs, live, and do not want to know, either. Their reaction to seeing such people is only disgust and fear.

Of late, I too have been noticing quite a considerable increase in the number of eunuchs at city traffic junctions, and, indeed, walking along various shopping areas. They are very much in-your-face in their approach, and take full advantage of people’s aversion to them to demand money,rather than beg for it. This, in turn, only serves to increase the disgust of people, and it’s turning into a vicious cycle.

When I struck up conversation with one “hijda”, she (because she was dressed as a woman) was initially very rude, but since we were both having “mini tea” at a small shop, she must have felt that I was not disgusted or asking questions out of prurient curiosity, so she finally did answer some of my questions. She said that all “normal” people hold them in great scorn and aversion, and they find it difficult to get any kind of paid, “respectable” jobs. “You people say it’s hard to find jobs!” she laughed brassily, “Can you imagine what it’s like for us?” She said that their society, too had organized mafia, and they had to pay up. “So we use this technique to get some money for ourselves,” she defended herself. “We are not beggars.” But, I questioned, was demanding money in shops and on the street, not begging? “No!” she said defiantly, “I don’t know any other way to make a living. I am always in debt.” When I asked her if, indeed, she could not find any other job, she winked at me suggestively, “Yes, I do the oldest job in the world, too!”

By this time, we were surrounded by a crowd of people very busily pretending NOT to be listening avidly to our conversation. She abruptly felt the attention, I think…without a further word, she turned her back on me and clapped her hands in the distinctive way of hijdas, and started asking for money. The crowd quickly melted. She had not even told me her name….and she absolutely refused to let me photograph her.

I do notice an increase in the number of the members of the third sex at all traffic intersections and shopping areas in Bangalore; and was unable to ask her why. Is there some political leeway being given to this community, to beg? Are there more factors behind the suddenly increased visiblity of the eunuchs of Bangalore? Between the sadness of being a “different” person, and the brazenness of demanding money in public…what is the reality of this shadow community of our city?

Support Citizen Matters - independent, Reader-funded media that covers your city like no other.DONATE
About Deepa Mohan 767 Articles
Deepa Mohan is a freelance writer and avid naturalist.


  1. I have studied their physical/psychological existence/behaviour through many available literature on such individuals. Basically they have vendetta against normal humans since they are deprived of decent living in our society. As human beings they can be employed in various activities positively rather than making them to snatch/beg. Police can regulate them by restricting their presence in traffic junctions.

  2. I do feel sorry for Hijdas. in fact they are very kind and loving. but because of our approach to them makes different in their personalities. one way we don’t considered them Humans. they have lot of energy which can be used in a industries. but is there any industry or place who can give them job? I had visited Hijdas dwelling area in Bhopal, in fact they are very rich and they adopt children and take care of them as their own child. one thing i have always notice that they never blame GOD of what they are today but try to survive by asking money from people. of course now a days we find lots of them in the city signals or market even they go to house to house asking money (i will say demanding) as though it is their right. but one should know, most of them are fake. many are dressed like them because it is a easy way of getting money. let’s say it is a another technique of Begging.

Comments are closed.